Analyzing arguments

Structure the lesson by starting with teacher-guided instruction, then provide activities in argument analysis individually and in small groups, and finally provide class discussion to summarize and clarify concepts. Instructional Procedures View Focus Question:

Analyzing arguments

Reading for Thinking - Online Practice: General distribution outside the classroom and redistribution are strictly prohibited.

Review each passage from Practice 1. Then click on the appropriate button Analyzing arguments identify the statement that supports the author's point of view.

This exercise cannot be done out of sequence.

Sample Arguments

It must be done following the completion of Practice 2. Thirty-one states in the U. Despite the ease and frequency of this practice, voters should not cast early ballots unless they have a truly legitimate reason, such as being physically unable to get to a polling place.

Casting early ballots is bad practice because it makes fraud more possible.

An Alternate Analysis: It might be suggested that the person making the above argument doesn't mean to make a merely hypothetical argument. That is, the person making the argument may be assuming that Clinton really did have an affair. Need to sign in through your campus portal? If you don't see your university listed, sign in above. Generating Ideas and Text In analyzing a text, your goal is to understand what it says, how it works, and what it means. To do so, you may find it helpful to follow a certain sequence: read, respond, summarize, analyze, and draw conclusions from your analysis.

Millions of ballots Analyzing arguments around America for over a month create the potential for a serious security breach. For example, an unscrupulous elections employee could make ballots disappear or fill out signed but unmarked ballots.


Early voting also prevents citizens from taking into account any late developments in a campaign. Something could happen shortly before Election Day and change a voter's opinion about the right candidate to elect, but the absentee ballot has already locked in his or her vote.

Then, too, Election Day is one of our country's last remaining ways of displaying communal patriotism. No-excuse absentee balloting prevents citizens from celebrating and showing pride in our democracy by being at the polls with our fellow Americans. To be sure, advocates of early voting say it increases voter participation; however, no evidence supports that claim.

On the contrary, sinceevery state with liberal rules for absentee ballots has actually experienced worse voter turnout than states without such rules. Which of the following statements could be used to support the author's point of view?

According to a study conducted by the Medill School of Journalism and the Campaign Study Group, failure to register is the non-voter's top reason for staying away from the polls.

Analyzing arguments

For example, absentee voting is popular in the state of Colorado; in the presidential election, Colorado had one of the highest absentee voting rates in the country. In fact, states with liberal absentee balloting rules saw voter turnout decline by 0.

Americans rarely just sit and eat.

1 Querying a Database

In a national poll, 62 percent of people surveyed admitted to being too busy to sit down for a meal.The strongest arguments, however, always rely on sound reasoning and strong evidence.” Collect students’ handouts to evaluate their understanding of the lesson. Extension.

Analyzing Argument. Aristotle hoped than mankind would embrace the logic of the syllogism and the enthymeme for making arguments. While he recognized the need for, and importance of, emotional appeals, he claimed that the affairs of mankind should be handled through logic.

This is the logical reasoning questions and answers section on "Analyzing Arguments" with explanation for various interview, competitive examination and entrance test. Solved examples with detailed answer description, explanation are given and it would be easy to understand. Provided below are some examples of students' answers on an exercise on analyzing arguments.

In this exercise students were asked to indicate if each passage is an argument or not and, if so, to identify the conclusion, premise(s), and issue. The Pale King: Analyzing “Good People” The first excerpt of The Pale King appeared in the February 5, issue of the New Yorker under the title “Good People.” At the time, there was no indication that this was a novel excerpt and Wallace had not published anything in the New Yorker in a long time (since , I believe, when a couple of Infinite Jest excerpts appeared).

Problems signing in? Create Password/Forgot Password (opens new window); Change Password/Update Expired Password (opens new window); What's My Username (opens new window); Alternate access (opens new window) in the event MyMTC is unavailable; How do I activate MyMTC account?

Analyzing Arguments - Logical Reasoning Questions and Answers